New data from the NOvA experiment at Fermilab in the US contain no evidence for so-called “sterile” neutrinos, in line with results from most – though not all – other neutrino detectors to date. As well as being consistent with previous experiments, the finding aligns with standard theoretical models of neutrino oscillation, in which three active types, or flavours, of neutrino convert into each other. The result also sets more stringent limits on how much an additional sterile type of neutrino could affect the others.
“The global picture on sterile neutrinos is still very murky, with a number of experiments reporting anomalous results that could be attributed to sterile neutrinos on one hand and a number of null results on the other,” says NOvA team member Adam Lister of the University of Wisconsin, Madison, US. “Generally, these anomalous results imply we should see large amounts of sterile-driven neutrino disappearance at NOvA, but this is not consistent with our observations.”
Neutrinos were first proposed in 1930 by Wolfgang Pauli as a way to account for missing energy and spin in the beta decay of nuclei. They were observed in the laboratory in 1956, and we now know that they come in (at least) three flavours: electron, muon and tau. We also know that these three flavours oscillate, changing from one to another as they travel through space, and that this oscillation means they are not massless (as was initially thought).
Significant discrepancies
Over the past few decades, physicists have used underground detectors to probe neutrino oscillation more deeply. A few of these detectors, including the LSND at Los Alamos National Laboratory, BEST in Russia, and Fermilab’s own MiniBooNE, have observed significant discrepancies between the number of neutrinos they detect and the number that mainstream theories predict.
One possible explanation for this excess, which appears in some extensions of the Standard Model of particle physics, is the existence of a fourth flavour of neutrino. Neutrinos of this “sterile” type do not interact with the other flavours via the weak nuclear force. Instead, they interact only via gravity.
Detecting sterile neutrinos would fundamentally change our understanding of particle physics. Indeed, some physicists think sterile neutrinos could be a candidate for dark matter – the mysterious substance that is thought to make up around 85% of the matter in the universe but has so far only made itself known through the gravitational force it exerts.
Near and far detectors
The NOvA experiment uses two liquid scintillator detectors to monitor a stream of neutrinos created by firing protons at a carbon target. The near detector is located at Fermilab, approximately 1 km from the target, while the far detector is 810 km away in northern Minnesota. In the new study, the team measured how many muon-type neutrinos survive the journey through the Earth’s crust from the near detector to the far one. The idea is that if fewer neutrinos survive than the conventional three-flavour oscillations picture predicts, some of them could have oscillated into sterile neutrinos.
The experimenters studied two different interactions between neutrinos and normal matter, says team member V Hewes of the University of Cincinnati, US. “We looked for both charged current muon neutrino and neutral current interactions, as a sterile neutrino would manifest differently in each,” Hewes explains. “We then compared our data across those samples in both detectors to simulations of neutrino oscillation models with and without the presence of a sterile neutrino.”
No excess of neutrinos seen
Writing in Physical Review Letters, the researchers state that they found no evidence of neutrinos oscillating into sterile neutrinos. What is more, introducing a fourth, sterile neutrino did not provide better agreement with the data than sticking with the standard model of three active neutrinos.
This result is in line with several previous experiments that looked for sterile neutrinos, including those performed at T2K, Daya Bay, RENO and MINOS+. However, Lister says it places much stricter constraints on active-sterile neutrino mixing than these earlier results. “We are really tightening the net on where sterile neutrinos could live, if they exist,” he tells Physics World.
The NOvA team now hopes to tighten the net further by reducing systematic uncertainties. “To that end, we are developing new data samples that will help us better understand the rate at which neutrinos interact with our detector and the composition of our beam,” says team member Adam Aurisano, also at the University of Cincinnati. “This will help us better distinguish between the potential imprint of sterile neutrinos and more mundane causes of differences between data and prediction.”
NOvA co-spokesperson Patricia Vahle, a physicist at the College of William & Mary in Virginia, US, sums up the results. “Neutrinos are full of surprises, so it is important to check when anomalies show up,” she says. “So far, we don’t see any signs of sterile neutrinos, but we still have some tricks up our sleeve to extend our reach.”
The post Sterile neutrinos are a no-show (again) appeared first on Physics World.